One Year Later: The Science Behind The Deadly Tennessee Tornadoes

It’s been one year since deadly tornadoes hit Middle Tennessee leaving a path of destruction and 19 people dead in Putnam County.  The aftermath left complete devastation as you can see in the photo gallery below but it also brought a community together.  Thousands of volunteers poured into the Upper Cumberland to help clean up and rebuild.

Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-46Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-47Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-48Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-49Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-50Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-51Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-52Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-53Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-54Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-55Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-56Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-57Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-58Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-59Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-60Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-61Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-62Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-63Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-64Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-65Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-66Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-67Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-68Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-69Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-70Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-71Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-72Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-73Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-74Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-75Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-76Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-77Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-78Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-79Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-80Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-81Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-82Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-83Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-84Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-85Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-86Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-87Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-88Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-89Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-90Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-91Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-92Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-93Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-94Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-95Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-96Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-97Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-98Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-99Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-100Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-101Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-102Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-103Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-104Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-105Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-106Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-107Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-108Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-109Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-110Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-111Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-112Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-113Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-114Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-115Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-116Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-117Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-118Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-119Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-120Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-121Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-122Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-123Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-124Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-125Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-126Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-127Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-128Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-129Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-130Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-131Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-132Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-133Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-134Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-135Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-136Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-137Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-138Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-139Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-140Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-141Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-142Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-143Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-144Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-145Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-146Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-147Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-148Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-149Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-150Tornado Damage in Putnam County 3-3-20 by David-151

Meteorologist Nicole Madden helped break down the science behind the deadly tornadoes.

How It Happened:

An EF-4 tornado tore through Cookeville killing 19 people and injuring dozens more.  This was the strongest-rated tornado the nation has seen in nearly three years.

An approaching cold front from the west interacted with a warm moist airmass triggering dangerous rotating thunderstorms, or supercells that produced deadly tornadoes killing 25 people, injuring 309 people, and leaving a widespread path of destruction across four counties.

The Timing:

According to The National Weather Service in Nashville, the initial tornado touched down at 12:32 a.m. on March 3, 2020, a little more than 3.5 miles WSW of John C Tune Airport as a strong EF-2 tornado and quickly moved into North Nashville and Germantown.

From there it strengthened to an EF-3 as it traveled into East Nashville, causing the most significant damage in and around the Five Points Neighborhood – where two people were killed. A path of EF-1 to EF-2 damage continued across the Cumberland River before the storm once again strengthened to an EF-3 in Donelson. Winds of 111 to 135 mph were observed across Hermitage and the remainder of Davidson County.

The storm strengthened for a third time as it moved into Wilson County, killing 3 people in Mt. Juliet. From there, damage associated with an EF-1 to EF-2 strength continued on a path along and occasionally across I-40, before finally lifting a little over 3.5 miles west of Gordonsville in Smith County at 1:28 a.m., stretching 53.4 miles, with maximum winds of 165 mph. This tornado killed five people and injured more than 150 people with a maximum width of 800 yards.

Nocturnal 2

The tornado touched down in Putnam County at 1:49 a.m. and lasted until 1:57 a.m. local time.

The Damage In Putnam County:

The EF-4 tornado that traveled across western and central Putnam County, Tennessee resulted in 19 deaths and 87 injuries.

The estimated peak winds were 175mph.  The path length of the tornado was 8.21 miles.  The max width was 500 yards.

Officials say 400 homes were damaged in Putnam County alone.  Thirty-one commercial structures were also damaged in the tornado that traveled parallel to Highway 70 between Baxter and Cookeville.  The Mayor of Cookeville said 100 residences were completely destroyed.

This is the path of the EF-4 tornado in Putnam County:

Baxtercookevilletormap

Officials with the National Weather Service say:

The tornado began 2.5 miles northwest of Baxter where it produced EF-0 damage for 2.7 miles as it crossed Gainesboro Highway.  The tornado intensified to EF-1 and EF-2 intensity in the Prosperity Pointe subdivision just north of US 70N/Nashville Highway and further intensified to EF-3 as it crossed Bloomington Road and Clemmons Road, severely damaging several homes.

Screen Shot 2020 03 06 At 10.11.36 Am

Home severely damaged in Cookeville, Tennessee. Photo credit: Upper Cumberland Reporter

The tornado then became violent for 0.8 miles as it entered the area around McBroom Chapel Road, where it reached EF-4 intensity, completely destroyed over a dozen homes, and caused numerous fatalities, with the heaviest damage concentrated on Hensley Drive. EF-4 damage continued eastward to Echo Valley Drive, where an apartment complex was completely destroyed.

West Wood Apartments

Damage in Cookeville, Tennessee. Photo credit: Upper Cumberland Reporter

EF-2 and EF-3 damage continued eastward for 2.0 miles, affecting homes along us 70N/W Broad Street, before rapidly coming to an end near N Franklin Avenue just west of Cookeville Regional Medical Center.

The Victims From Putnam County:

Todd Koehler

Sue Koehler

Terry Curtis

Dawson Curtis

Joshua Kimberlin

Erin Kimberlin

Sawyer Kimberlin

Keith Selby

Cathy Selby

Jessica Clark

Amanda Cole

Hattie Collins

Patricia “Pat” Lane

Stephanie Fields

Harlan Marsh

Bridgette (Ann Marie) McCormick

Jamie Smith

Leisha Littenberry

Robert Dickson

Tornado History For Tennessee:

This marked the first violent tornado in middle Tennessee since April 10, 2009, but not the last for the state – EF-4 tornadoes were confirmed in western Tennessee in 2015 and eastern Tennessee in 2011.

Tennessee averages 30 tornadoes across the state per year, and 17 within Middle Tennessee alone. In fact, this is not even the first tornado for the city of Nashville, with the last occurring in 1998.

March marks the beginning of severe weather season for the majority of the southeast with the most tornadoes occurring between March and June.

Nocturnal Tornadoes:

One of the reasons why these tornadoes were so deadly was due to the time they occurred and the breakdown of communication and understanding within the general public of severe weather.

According to a study in 2007 by Walker Ashley, nocturnal tornadoes, or tornadoes between sunset and sunrise, account for 27% of all tornadoes within the continental U.S. However, of all tornadoes between 1950 and 2005 that occurred in Tennessee, 45.8% occurred at night – more than any other state in the country.

More than 24% of tornadoes within the Carolinas occur at night. The study goes on to report, that tornadoes that occur between midnight and sunrise are 2.5 times more likely to kill than those that occur during the day – with North Carolina ranking first for fatalities during nocturnal killer tornadoes.

Nocturnal Tornadoes1

Peak Tornado Season:

Although peak severe weather season is during the spring, during the late afternoon hours – severe weather can occur at any time of year, during any time of day, at any place. In fact, the transition between the cool and spring seasons is when the highest nocturnal fatality rates occur. Why? A general misunderstanding that tornadoes only occur during the warmer months can lead people to be caught off guard to these early season severe events.

Issuing Severe Weather Warnings:

The threat of severe weather earlier this week was expressed by both the Storm Prediction Center and the National Weather Service lead. As well as meteorologists from local news outlets – who stayed on-air for hours to track the tornadoes and bring information to the public once tornado warnings were issued.

Although the threat of severe weather was low, the threat of tornadoes was still expressed. These tornadoes developed rapidly within a conducive environment to support long-lasting severe weather.

The biggest problem with these storms was that they developed after midnight when most people were asleep without any alert to wake them of the impending danger. Meteorologists bring you information before, during and after severe weather – but, staying WeatherWise to the latest forecast and having multiple forms of weather alerts that will wake you during nighttime storms are critical.

Importance Of Weather Radios:

Outdoor warning sirens are meant to alert people outside to seek the shelter of potential tornadoes, not for those already indoors and should not be used as your only warning during severe weather.

The outdoor warning sirens did go off in Putnam County as the deadly EF-4 tornado was approaching.  However, the storm hit at 1:49 a.m. and many people simply didn’t hear the warnings.

A weather radio is a reliable warning system and can be programmed to alert you of any severe watch or warning for where you live – even if the power goes out or if there is no cell service.  These radios cost less than $30.

Smartphones can also alert you of a tornado, flash flood or tsunami warning through the Wireless Emergency Alert system. You can activate it through your notification settings.

One important tip is to make sure your phone is fully charged if you know severe weather is in the area. A portable phone charger is also a great product that can help keep your phone powered for an extended period of time during natural disasters.